Technical Jury Note
An honest reviewer map for what is canonical, what is supplemental, what is preview-only, and what remains roadmap.
Frozen for reproducibility
Canonical proof
The canonical reviewer proof is DAO-PROP-6CB25C. It remains fixed so judges can verify the same evidence chain, Casper receipt, IPFS archive, recorded SafePay Lite proof, and certificate without the proof hierarchy shifting during review.
Canonical receipte926582f3dac…c286d852Canonical contracthash-a864046…5caa42f1IPFS CIDbafkreih4jw6…4qhahfyq
Additional evidence, not replacement
Supplemental proofs
Quorumv2 quorum-enabled contract proves pre-quorum rejection, wallet approval, and final post-quorum receipt.
WalletRecorded browser wallet receipt demonstrates custody path without making the demo depend on a judge wallet.
DynamicSupplemental dynamic proposal proves reusable receipt execution while the canonical proof stays frozen.
x402 · CASPER-TRANSFER · RECORDED SETTLEMENTCasper-native x402 v2 is deployed. The public endpoint exposes a live HTTP 402 challenge, and a recorded Casper Testnet casper-transfer settlement finalized successfully. No external facilitator service is claimed.
Two real GovernanceReceipt iterations plus supplemental topology
Smart contract proof table
| Surface | Proposal / date | Proof hash | Reviewer meaning |
|---|---|---|---|
| Canonical reviewer proof | DAO-PROP-6CB25C | e926582f3dac…c286d852 | Frozen reproducible Casper receipt |
| v1 GovernanceReceipt contract | Jun 29 | hash-a864046…5caa42f1 | Receipt anchor used by canonical reviewer proof |
| Browser wallet receipt | DAO-PROP-6CB25C | 56b6ea6ccaae…be4f12bf | Recorded Casper Wallet custody path |
| Quorum-enabled v2 proof | DAO-PROP-6CB25C | 9d631fe1c925…9efe2928 | Supplemental receipt after quorum approval |
| Supplemental dynamic execution | DAO-PROP-DYN-002 | 68fd77bc4f59…5e4040e0 | Reusable engine proof, not canonical |
| SafePay Lite (recorded V1 native-CSPR) | DAO-PROP-6CB25C | dcb35f429590…a6d4914c | Historical payment and duplicate-proof rejection evidence |
| IPFS archive | DAO-PROP-6CB25C | bafkreih4jw6…4qhahfyq | Pinned governance archive CID |
Reusable engine, controlled execution
Dynamic preview boundary
Non-canonical proposals can build dynamic preview artifacts and testnet intent previews when evidence exists. They are not automatically advertised as canonical executed proofs unless a processed Casper transaction is captured and listed in the proof table.
This avoids fake success states while still showing how the verifier, invariant runner, DAO Mandate builder, and wallet intent packager generalize.
No overclaiming
Live vs roadmap
AvailableCanonical receipt, Proof Center, Judge Walkthrough, browser wallet receipt, quorum proof, Casper-native x402 v2 payment intent, recorded V1 native-CSPR SafePay Lite evidence, IPFS archive, PDF/HTML certificate, and verifier artifacts.
SupplementalOdra topology genesis and dynamic proposal receipts are supporting proofs, not replacements for the canonical reviewer proof.
RoadmapFull cross-contract production enforcement, enterprise IAM/durable queues, and SSE finality pipeline remain launch-plan work.
One-command reviewer checks
Verifier commands
Show local verification commands
uv run pytest -q tests/ -q uv run python scripts/verify_concordia_receipt.py artifacts/live/casper-final-receipt-proof.json uv run python scripts/check_canonical_consistency.py uv run python scripts/redaction_check.py